
Alamy 2026
Dear {{first_name | Friend}},
Of all the indignities visited on the generation who came of age over the past 15 years, that we should resort to cliche when describing their monumental betrayal seems to me among the most offensive. Thousands of nouns are available to us as potential candidates to qualify the acronym NEETs, for those Not in Education, Employment, or Training in modern Britain. Yet, as cliche would have it, “Crisis” is the one our journalism - which is meant to be a war against cliche - has gone for. As I type this, I have put “NEETs crisis” into the Google News tab and - Lo! - headlines abound, uniting The Daily Telegraph, The Guardian, and Civil Service World with my former employers, The Independent and the BBC. All refer to a “NEETs crisis”.
And yet “crisis” is the wrong word, because it conceals the precise nature of the very thing in front of us. The Cambridge Dictionary says a crisis is “a time of great disagreement, confusion, or suffering”, or - more pointedly - “an extremely difficult or dangerous point in a situation.” That suggests it is acute. But the whole point - the whole damn point - about our NEETs situation is that it is chronic. Yes it’s an emergency, in that failure to act will lead to terrible pain - but it is chronic, because our NEETs rate has, amazingly, stayed at roughly this level for 20 years. See this graph from the always useful Simon French:

Simon French, @frencheconomics
It is an entire generation that has been failed. And an entire generation of politics and politicians that has failed them.
For two decades, we haven’t really got the rate below 10%. After a surge following the Great Financial Crash, it came down during the Coalition years, but is now spiking post-Covid.
This the greatest catastrophe of our age. At least “NEET-zero” has the benefit of being a pun rather than cliche - and a laudable goal. (NEET-zero means an effective rate of 5%, which would put us ahead of the Netherlands, the European country with the lowest rate). A country of our size that lets a million young people waste away is not a country that knows its true potential. And for each of those young people, many of whom will never work, and almost all of whom will fail to optimise what should be some of the best and most exciting years of their life, the human waste is unforgivable.
Step forward, Alan Milburn. The former Labour Cabinet member, who grew up on a council estate and was often spoken of as a potential successor to Tony Blair, has done a substantial and serious bit of work. For that he should be applauded. There are shortcomings, which I’ll get to; but it is a close to comprehensive analysis, honest about the trade-offs, with many good recommendations.
The Milburn Report gets four big things right. Before the practicalities, there is a shift in principle which is worthwhile. Young people presenting as unable to earn or learn should, in the first instance, be asked not what they can’t do, but what they can do. That is not just semantics. It flips the system on its head. The greater emphasis on social duty and contribution, and the lower tolerance for marginal cases, will make a difference.
Second, there are specific reforms to particular benefits which improve incentives. So young people won’t get the health top-up to universal credit, for instance. That - as Milburn acknowledges, will hurt for some - costing young people potentially £50-100: a huge sum.
Third, it is an abomination that for every £25 we have spent on income support (i.e. benefits for those not in work), we have spent just £1 on employment support (i.e. helping people find work). That will change.
And the legal guarantee that Milburn is suggesting, where every young person has a legal right, backed by statute, to earn or learn, is commendable. It puts the strong arm of the law behind each young person’s aspiration. There may be challenges with enforcement of course.
But for a report with such ostensible ambition, and which is the culmination of years of thought for Milburn, who set himself up (justifiably) as an heir to William Beveridge, the report is curiously… lacking in ambition. It suggests that savings will be realised in… 9 years. Basically a decade before the savings come in. That’s just far too long. We haven’t got 9 years. A target for realised savings in 3 to 5 years would have been much more politically galvanising.
I’m alarmed too to read that Tom Waters, estimable Associate Director of the Institute of Fiscal Studies, should conclude that there’s “just no detail” to justify the claim that these reforms would increase employment by 440,000. That seems more than an oversight.
Most dispiriting of all is the briefing already coming out of the Treasury to suggest that cutting taxes on Business would deliver poor value for money. The Treasury is full of such smart people, often doing heroic work for less money than they could get elsewhere. But they do sometimes give the impression of never having worked in a business. On Thursday morning, a report in the Financial Times claimed: “UK Treasury opposes flagship plan to tackle youth unemployment.”
Oh dear. Milburn, mindful of political reality and uppity backbenchers, massively caveated his recommendations by saying that cutting taxes for businesses that want to hire should only happen “when fiscal conditions allow”. I know Milburn would have been up for a fight with the Treasury on this, and I wish he’d just said to No. 10 that they should do this now.
I don’t want to be cynical. Yes, the timescale was weirdly distant; yes, there are doubts as to whether all the numbers are accurate; and yes, I wish he’d boldly said we need to cut taxes on business now.
For all that, Alan Milburn’s big report is the first time in over a decade that there is real political momentum behind trying to address the desperate struggle of a million young people who are failing to launch. I wish he’d gone further, and faster. If Whitehall bureaucracy or sheer political cowardice stop even his relatively modest reforms being enacted, that will be the latest confirmation that the rulers of my beloved country have lost both their marbles and their morals.
The Nobility of an ex-PM. Yes, really.
No doubting my moment of the week last week. It was in the Commons. The member for Richmond in Yorkshire and Northallerton stood up and told the leader of the House, that he had “recently convened a meeting of North Yorkshire council, the mayor’s office, and TransPennine Express, to discuss the shortage of car parking at Northallerton train station.” He went on: “Will he join me in encouraging all parties to work constructively together to find a solution for our local community.”
Our system has many flaws, but the strong constituency representation is a strength. So much of the beauty of democracy is in the banal rituals, quotidian eccentricities, and weird formalities that take place in Westminster. The nobility of its practitioners lies in the fact that they don’t have to be there. Of nobody - nobody - is this truer than Rishi Sunak.

Facebook: Will Calverley
Last week, Sunak was re-elected as the Conservative candidate for Richmond and Northallerton. That means he will almost certainly serve another 5 years in Parliament. He is the first ex-Prime Minister to stand again after an election they lost since Jim Callaghan.
I think occasionally of the mauling Sunak got, in the press, Commons, and social media, about his deep links to California. Having studied at Stanford, and met his wife there, he owns a property in the Golden State. He also combines parliamentary and constituency duties with advisory work for Microsoft, Anthropic, and Goldman Sachs (all within the rules), and a (presumably ghosted) column in The Sunday Times, the fee for which is redirected to his charity, The Richmond Project, which aims to give kids confidence with numbers.
It is true that, through his own career in the City, Sunak became extremely rich, and through his marriage, astronomically so. But when you think of what he could do with his time - not the money he could earn, but golf he could play, or Tolstoy he could finally read - that he should commit to his constituents and represent their concerns about station parking is not just laudable. It is noble.
We are right to worry that the calibre of politicians has fallen very dramatically in recent years. But we do have some distinguished ex-PMs. For instance, I have got to know John Major and Gordon Brown in recent years, and hope to bring both to you on the show. Their careers after politics are similarly suffused with public spirit. For all that we are right to feel politics over the past generation or so has mostly failed to deliver what the people want, need and deserve, there are some high calibre people doing it for the right reasons. The member for Richmond and Northallerton is one.
Your one great question, please, for Professor Sarah Blagden, who might just deliver a vaccine for Cancer

Genomics England.
Our overall mission on The Amol Rajan Connection - aside from building this beautiful club - is to slow your world down, explain the deep forces and trends shaping our era, and help you win the Future. Within that mission are a series of huge sub-plots, or passions: areas of interest that I know really matter to you, as they do to me. NEETs, poverty and social mobility, for instance; AI and our relationship with technology; the future of Education; financial literacy and investing (expect lots more on this); and longevity. Within longevity, curing diseases like cancer.
I am so, so excited that Professor Sarah Blagden of the University of Oxford is coming on our show. She is one of the most venerated oncologists in the world. I revere scientists, and think it’s a failing in our culture that we give them so little of the public adulation they deserve. Well, together with her team, Professor Blagden is one of the - if not the main - candidates to finally get what some see as a Holy Grail in medicine: a vaccine for Cancer.
Can you imagine if they - if she - pulls that off?
Most of our lives have been touched by Cancer. My mum went through non-Hodgkins Lymphoma 15 years ago. I will ask Professor Blagden all the basics, including what Cancer actually is, but it’s you I want to hear from, because she will be answering your questions in our bonus QUARC episode.
Your one great question, please, about Cancer or otherwise, for Professor Sarah Blagden, to [email protected] - and yes we do like it if you can send a voice note or even video note. Thank you.
Save Our Farmers!
Goodness me, what a force of nature (pun intended) Minette Batters, the first woman to lead the National Farmers Union, is. And - blimey! - what a response to her coming on the show.
The plight of our farmers could not be more urgent. Links to the full episode below:
For our early access subscribers, you can listen to the Q&A with Minette Batters below:

THE AMOL RAJAN CONNECTION - Q&A EARLY ACCESS
Early Access Q&A with Minette Batters: Farming, food security and a warning.
I will not be silenced (alas)
Many of you have very kindly written in saying that I should read the audio version of this newsletter on the website, rather than the current, automated, American voice. Well, that's fair enough. Thanks for asking.
There are just so many things to sort out as we launch ARC that the audio version of this newsletter is one of those where we thought we'd experiment. We're experimenting constantly on all fronts as we grow, and learning more from what we get wrong than what we get right. Good.
Vox populi, vox Dei, and all that jazz: I shall read the audio version of this newsletter. I can't guarantee it will be from next week - sorry! - as we have so many glorious workflows to sort out. But it will be soon, and I hope it's useful.
The ARC of Recommends
Read:
Thanks so so much to the wonderful and wise Megan, an ARC subscriber, who wrote in to the club, following my recommendation last week of Unicornia, to say that I should try Unipiggle by Hannah Shaw, which she’s been reading with her 5 year-old daughter. Two of my daughters are 5 and 3 so I ordered some copies, thinking they look right up their street. And… they loved them! What a win, for ARC, for literature, for civilisation - and for unicorns! Thank you again, Megan. This is exactly what belonging to a club is all about.
Visit:
I’ve been filming the Christmas series of University Challenge in Salford. Every day, after we finish filming, I have the same routine. I feel so guilty about being away from my kids that I feel like I have to optimise my time, and also get fit so I can be around for them as long as possible. So I go for a run, usually about 8km, along the tram route, round the two Old Traffords, and then back to Salford Quays. It’s a pretty ghastly route to be frank - all industrial badlands and 3 lane highways. But I end up right opposite Media City, and go to a Jamaican restaurant and bar called Turtle Bay, where it always seems to happy hour, the staff always seem to be smiling, they always play great reggae, and you can always get plantain and jerk chicken with hot sauce for a snip. Heaven.
Watch:
Love Actually. I know, I know. I’d never actually watched it. I’m sorry. And I know some people think it’s plotless nonsense. But it’s romantic and funny and well acted plotless nonsense if so. Oh and it’s not plotless at all. It’s several different romantic tales, all ending in the same pleasing if saccharine way, and sometimes you just want to watch a soppy romance, ok? Oh and the cast is so ridiculous, and launched so many careers, that even if you don’t like soppy Richard Curtis movies, you’ll enjoy being astonished at the people in it. It’s almost like an episode of ‘Before They Were Famous’. I saw it for the first time last weekend, and you’d enjoy it.
Listen:
Desert Island Discs, with Professor Hannah Fry. I sent Hannah a voice-note this week, because I was in floods of tears on the train. I knew her a bit before Celebrity Traitors, but you never really know anyone, do you? Except, after hearing this show you’ll feel you do know her much better. Hannah is a very, very special person, and I think we see the world in similar ways. I’m a Desert Island Discs anorak, listening to ancient episodes when I go running, and this is undoubtedly one of the all-time greats. Her track selection is hilarious - yes, PJ and Duncan make it in - and the scene she describes after her major surgery when she had cancer will break your heart. Huge credit to Lauren for doing such a brilliant job.
Member Perks
The shop is open! The shop is open! Ring the bells and shout it from the rooftops!
The ARC shop is open! Actual merch! That’s merch, for “merchandise”.
Our branding, designed by the great Serge Seidlitz - genuinely the best illustrator of his generation - and inspired by Jimmy Cliff in The Harder They Come, is now on actual t-shirts, hoodies, and tote bags. I can’t quite believe it.

Remember, those of you in the Margarita and Dark & Stormy tier get a 20% discount; those of you in the Negroni and Pina Colada tier get an even sweeter 30% discount.
Thank you so much to those of you who upgraded last week. We appreciate it more than you might imagine, and you are doing so much to help us build something really useful in the world: not just a business, but a club, and a home for independent thought. Thank you.
As a thank you, the behind-the-scenes (BTS) footage now live on the website, and only available to paying Members, includes the highly emotional scene when I opened the chunky envelope with the first ever ARC merch. A dream come true!
Happy Saturday, and I hope you have a lovely weekend.
Yours ARCfully,
AMOL


